1999 World Congress of Sexology

GENDER IDENTITY DISORDER IN JAPAN: A CLINICAL SURVEY OF 194 OUTPATIENTS


  Katsuki Harima and Teruo Abe
Tokyo Family Court1 and Abe Mental Clinic
Tokyo, Japan



INTRODUCTION

 Medical treatment as well as even discussion of gender identity disorder (GID) have long been practically a taboo in Japan. For this reason some patients with GID have got sex reassignment surgery (SRS) in other countries, while others have received hormonal therapy and/or SRS underground at home. This situation, however, is now changing. In 1998 Dr.Harashina performed the first SRS in Japan that was legally admitted. Patients who visit a doctor are increasing in number.

MATERIALS AND METHOD

 We report on our study of the data of 194 out-patients who visited Abe Mental Clinic and were diagnosed as having GID according to DSM-IV. 79 patients are FTM (female to male)and 115 patients are MTF(male to female).

RESULTS

1. Age
 Age distribution of FTM peaks in 3rd decade and that of MTF in 4th decade. These results correspond with those in other countries. The youngest patient is a 16 year old MTF and the oldest one is a 78 MTF.
2. Motivation for their visit
 139 patients wanted for psychotherapy. Some only for psychotherapy, others for psychotherapy as a step to go on to hormonal treatment or SRS. 52 patients wanted for medical information. Some patients come to ask what the GID is and others ask if there are any good peer support groups. 3 patients needed a medical certificate for change of their registered name or other reasons.
3. Social status
 44 patients work as a part timer. Some patients do so because they don't want to wear a typical gender role uniform or because they don't want to tell their boss their registered sex. 17 patients are unemployed. Some were fired because of GID. 6 patients receive welfare aids.
4. Education
 Some patients didn't go on to high school, because they did not want to wear a school uniform or a swimming suit or because they wanted to avoid being teased by classmates and teachers.
5. School refusal
 The average rate of school refusal in Japan is below 2%. Therefore 35% is significantly higher. There are some reasons for this. The biggest reason is teasing. Another reason is the uniform. They did not want to wear a school uniform, a swimming suit, or a gymnastic wear.
6. Divorce of their parents
 About 10% parents of Japanese children get divorced. Therefore 20 % is higher than the average. The relation between their parents divorce and GID is yet to be known.
       7. Partner
 Yes means the patients have or had a partner. No means the patients have never had a partner. A partner is hard to get for MTF.
8. Sexual orientation
 FTM patients tend to be attracted to female. MTF patients have various sexual orientations. These results correspond with those in other countries.
9. Hormonal therapy.
 Some patients have already begun to be on hormonal therapy without a psychiatrist's permission. Some patients have got hormonal therapy without a medical check-up or informed consent on the risk of side effects.
10. Surgery
 Some patients had already got surgical therapy. 23 FTM patients underwent mastectomy. Now they can enjoy hot summer with or without a T shirt. 4 MTF patients reduced Adams' apple to get a female neck line. 12 MTF patients removed their testes to reduce their androgen level. 29 MTF patients got electrolysis to remove their facial hair permanently.
11. Change of registered name
 19 FTM patients changed their first name from typical female name to typical male or non sexual related name. 17 MTF patients did the opposite. Today a growing number of patients are changing their registered name. This is mainly because nowadays they can easily change their first name when diagnosed as having GID. Presently they can change their first name, but not change their registered sex in Japan.

CONCLUSION

 Our results show many GID patients have many problems: educational, social, economical and psychological and patients who want medical help are increasing in number. It is concluded that both social and medical support system should be established to improve the QOL of GID patients.



SUBJECTS

FTM MTF Total
79 115 194
1984~1996:4
1997~1999:190


RESULTS

1. Age

  FTM MTF Total
~19 2 5 7
20~29 55 38 93
30~39 19 55 74
40~49 2 15 17
50~ 1 2 3


2. Motivation for their visit

  FTM MTF Total
Psychotherapy 61 78 139
Medical information 17 35 52
Medical certificate 1 2 3


3. Social status

  FTM MTF Total
Full-time job 36 75 111
Part-time job 22 22 44
Student 13 9 22
Unemployed 8 9 17


4. Education

  FTM MTF Total
University 36 58 87
Vocational school 10 12 22
High school 33 39 72
Junior high school: 7 6 13


5. School refusal

  FTM MTF Total
Yes 25(32%) 43(37%) 68(35%)
No 54(68%) 72(63%) 126(65%)


6. Divorce of their parents

  FTM MTF Total
Yes 21(26%) 17(15%) 38(20%)
No 58(74%) 98(85%) 156(80%)


7. Sexual partner

  FTM MTF Total
Yes 58(73%) 40(35%) 98(51%)
No 21(27%) 75(65%) 96(49%)


8. Sexual orientation

  FTM MTF
to male 2 53
to female 71 31
to both 6 30
to neither 0 1


9. Hormonal therapy

  FTM MTF Total
Yes 51(65%) 77(68%) 128(66%)
No 28(35%) 38(32%) 66(34%)


10. Surgery

  FTM MTF
Mastectomy 23  
Thyroid cartilage shave 4  
Orchiectomy 12  
Orchiectomy 7  
Electrolysis 29  


11. Change of registered name

  FTM MTF Total
Yes 19(24%) 17(15%) 36(19%)
No 60(76%) 98(85%) 158(81%)